Change accompanies us throughout life. We move from childhood to adulthood, then into our senior years. Of course, other markers of change occur within those three life stages. Likewise, change characterizes Christianity. Three moments highlight Christianity's ongoing changes.
The first: Christianity separated from Judaism (roughly in the 1st and 2nd centuries CE). It is unclear whether the earliest leadership intended to establish the Jesus movement as a separate “religion.” Acts 15 reports an effort by Peter and James to negotiate an agreement to keep Jewish and Gentile Christians together. According to the text, Paul, the former rabbi, was instrumental in the division. But other literature from the time indicates that Paul was not the only one involved.
Problems had been brewing for a long time between the Christian leadership in Rome and Constantinople. Finally, arguments over the Nicene Creed, adopted at the 2nd Council of Nicaea (382 CE), provided what the two groups “may have wanted.” The Creed stated that the Holy Spirit came from the Father. However, the West began using a variant: the Holy Spirit came from the Father and the Son. In 1054, the Eastern Patriarch and the Western Pope excommunicated each other over the inclusion of “and the Son” (filioque).
A third major division, the one we know best, is the emergence of “Protestantism.” We celebrate this division as “the Reformation.” We usually identify this Reformation as originating in Martin Luther's theological argument with the leadership in Rome, specifically either his public display of the 95 Theses against the “authorized” theology and practices (1517) or his excommunication by the Pope (1521). But, of course, “Protests” against Rome’s control over Western Christianity began before Luther. Division within Christianity has continued to this day.
October 31, Reformation Day: What constitutes a reform? In part, that depends on which side you're on: is the division a reform, heresy, or simply a rupture?
The definition of a reformation is not obvious. Many groups that split from the existing church consider their split a reformation, calling the church back to its faith and mission. Nevertheless, a couple of signs can indicate that a movement is an effort to reform rather than merely separate.
Is division the agenda? Originally, Luther did not intend to start a new church but to renew the church. John and Charles Wesley did not intend to establish a new denomination, Methodism. They remained in the Anglican Church their entire lives. For the most part, the Anabaptists and Pietists did not intend to leave the church. A large group of Pietists remained in the Lutheran Church in Germany, but others were persecuted, even thrown into prison or executed.
A reform movement aims to foster more faithful church witness and mission. Some monastic groups sought to restore a vital Christian witness and practice, but they did not split from the established church. However, when leaders leave and take charge of “their” congregation or denomination, the outcome is more likely to be schismatic than reformative.
We live in a time when polarization overshadows the hope of reform. Many voices raise concerns, some more equitable and faithful than others. Yet anger, fear, and the pursuit of power can distort even worthy aims. When defeating the other becomes the goal, the church forgets the very renewal it seeks. The most valuable Reformers remind us that genuine change begins not with perfect theology or correct politics, but with returning to the God whose love meets us before we are faithful — and remains with us even when we are divided.